Reese’s Cheesecake Brownies

Be sure and join me on Facebook for the latest updates on new recipes!


Talk about a peanut butter and chocolate overload of deliciousness!

These bad boys are intense and amazing!!I saw them floating around pinterest from Pip & Ebby forever ago, but didn’t pin them myself until recently and finally caved and made them! Yum!

Found recipe at: Pip & Ebby

1 fudge brownie mix (and anything it calls for)
1 (8 oz) pkg cream cheese
1 (14 oz) can sweetened condensed milk
1/2 cup creamy peanut butter
1 (12 oz) pkg Reese’s Pieces
1 (12 oz) pkg milk chocolate chips
3 Tbsp whipping cream
12 large Reese’s Peanut Butter cups (chopped)

Preheat oven to 350 F.  Lightly coat a 9×13 pan with cooking spray.
Prepare brownie batter according to its directions and pour batter into the 9×13 pan and set aside.In a large bowl, beat softened cream cheese until light and fluffy. Add in Sweetened condensed milk and peanut butter and beat until smooth.  Stir in bag of Reese’s Pieces candies.
Spoon Cheesecake mixture over brownie batter evenly.
Bake at 350 for 40 minutes or until cheesecake layer is set and edges are golden brown.
Let cool for 30 minutes then refrigerate for 30 minutes.
In a microwave safe bowl, add milk chocolate chips and whipping cream.  Melt on high for 1 minute checking and stirring throughout so  not to overcook.  Heat until melted and smooth.
Pour and spread evenly over the top of brownies/cheesecake.
Sprinkle the 12 large chopped Reese’s Peanut Butter cops over top.
Store Covered in refrigerator.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe


  1. From the Kitchen

    Oh my goodness! These look obscenely delicious! I'm looking for my grocery list right now.


  2. Dulce Dough

    Wow! This looks amazing!

  3. mamawolfe

    I can hardly wait to get home today to make these...thanks for driving me crazy!

  4. kadie dahl

    Come on! Sometimes I really hate reading your blog! It makes me so hungry! That looks so delicious! Can't wait to try it out!!!

  5. oomph.

    you had me at cheesecake. these look divine :)


  6. Michelle @ Loving Every Second

    Um, are you kidding me???? Those look very dangerous . . .

  7. Cherish

    Oh my heck....drooling....

  8. Lark (SparkyLarky)@ Lark's Country Heart

    Oh My flipping heck, these look so sinfully good!

  9. Mary

    OMG! I read reese's and clicked on this post so fast. I'm drooling here. I need to make this. There goes my diet.. again.

  10. Kate H.(

    So glad I'm going to the grocery store tonight. I definitely will be making these soon (:



  12. Pamela

    Drooling on my keyboard here...I'm lovin' all the recipes. My family is going to eat good next week!

  13. ASingleMothersJourney

    I guess I'll be going to the grocery store tomorrow because I'm making these!

  14. So Domesticated

    Yum! These look so good! Thanks for stopping by my blog!

  15. laurie

    These look amazing!

    Thanks for visiting my blog!

  16. Corina

    This looks absolutely delicious!
    I'll try them one day :P
    Thanks for sharing a have a nice weekend!

  17. Chels

    My husbands family would adore this!

  18. It's A Mom Thing

    You're killin' me over here! I've been craving cheesecake like crazy...and with Reese's? I'm in heaven!

  19. Antonella

    Oh my!!! Just what the doctor ordered (or not - lol) This looks so wonderfully good I am going to have to give it a try.
    Hugs, antonella :-)
    P.S. I am your newest follower, thanks for stopping by!

  20. Terry

    Found your yummy recipe on Pinterest..if you have time, come on over and link up at my party going on now.

  21. Steph

    Oh my gosh!!! My hubby's favorite candy is Reese's! I'll DEFINITELY be making these!
    Thanks for the follow! I'm returning the <3!!!
    :) Steph

  22. Jill

    Oh WOW! They would have to be cut into really small pieces! So devilishly good!

    Thanks for linking to a Round Tuit!
    Hope you have a great week!
    Jill @ Creating my way to Success

  23. Kristin

    Yum! Those look delicious!

  24. Shelley

    Well helllloooo lover!!! These look amaze-balls :D I MUST make these!

  25. Shanna @ Yellow Pocket Boutique

    Mouth watering..At 30 weeks pregnant I have every reason..or make and eat these by myself!Definitely going to try this recipe soon! Thanks!

  26. Katie @ The Crafty Blog Stalker

    Oh my! These look AMAZING!!! I have pinned this so I don't loose the recipe!I would love for you to share with my Blog Stalking Thursday Link Party Starting tomorrow!

  27. WithAShotOf_Brandy

    I am now so ready for the bake sale! Thanks for sharing. Hop over to Coffee & Conversations Thursday and share,please!

  28. Mei

    That looks amazing!!!!

  29. Kim McCallie

    That's some serious peanut butter! Looks amazing. Thanks for sharing on Sweet Indulgences Sunday.

  30. Kelly

    This sounds wonderful!! Reese Cups are one of my weaknesses! I'll probably replace the Reese's Pieces with nuts, though.

  31. Lisha @ DeLovely Life

    Made these using a brownie recipe from The brownies took forever to cook (about 60 minutes), but it still came out well. It was very rich and tasty.

  32. Sugarr2518

    These look soo good! I just might have to make these:)

  33. Faith

    This looks really good!!

  34. Deb

    Peanut allergies suck! :0(

  35. Ragan

    Ooh! Peanut butter and chocolate on a brownie! YUMMMMM!! Sounds amazing! Can't wait to try one!

  36. Anonymous

    Omg these look so good!! I can't believe it only takes these things I thought it would take a lot more.

  37. Anonymous

    I loved it... I made it tonight...Awesome! (:

  38. Emily

    Sold! Costco has a new KS brand peanut butter cup, and this recipe will help me get through the huge bag I couldn't resist buying last time I was there! Yum!

  39. Rachel Klopp

    Do you mean Reeses pieces that look like m & m's or the peanut butter chips in the bag?

  40. Local Deal Finder-Huntsville-Conroe-The Woodlands

    How did you keep your cream cheese mixture on top? When I tried this recipe, my cream cheese mixture was heavier than the brownie mixture and sank right where it plopped, and was practically impossible to spread all over the top of the brownie mixture...

  41. Candy

    I made these today and I they were a hit! I just swirled the cheesecake mixture into the brownie mixture and they turned out great. I also omitted the Reece's pieces (by mistake). Yummy!

  42. Anonymous

    I just made these - they look delicous! I feel like the proportions are not quite right though. I seem to have too much brownie mix compared to the cheese cake and reese's pieces. Also, I feel like the chocolate melting instructions may lead you to burn the chocolate - I'd recommend a lower temp and longer! All the spoon-licking was good though, so I'm sure the bars will be as well!

  43. Anonymous

    These look so good, I'm really trying to hold off making these cause they would be to much of a temptation!

  44. lisa

    These look yummy and great but were a bust when I made them. The brownies never cooked all the way through. The layer of peanut butter/cream cheese/reese's pieces barely covered the brownie and did not turn out thick like the picture. I was just very disappointed how it turned out, the money it cost to make the product and the fact I couldn't serve it at the function I made it for....I tossed it out. Hopefully someone else had a better outcome...please share if you did.

    1. Erin

      These didn't turn out at all. The brownies were still raw, there wasn't enough of the cheesecake layer, and the chocolate chips didn't melt right in the microwave. I'm really bummed that I spent all this time and money for nothing!

  45. Therapy Baker

    I made these they were good, but had to eat them with a fork since the brownies didn't cook all the way through. Did I miss something here?

  46. Sam

    I made these and for some reason could not get the chocolate to melt right (maybe I just wasn't used to the consistency it would make combined with the whipping cream). I tried twice but ran out of time and had to serve them anyway at a baby shower.
    I was told they were to die for and didn't even need the topping. People devoured them anyway. I'll probably continue to make them this way!