Ice Cream Sandwich Cake

First off, I don’t know if you have noticed, but I have a new “Recipe Index” tab up at the top.  I figured it was about time I make an index for all these recipes on this blog.  Hopefully this helps you find specific recipes with more ease and maybe discover some you haven’t seen before!Today’s recipe that is both simple and delicious.  Aren’t those the best kind?  I shared it at Mandy’s Recipe Blog last week, but in case you missed it I am reposting it here!  I posted this a while back on my blog, but I thought it was time for an updated picture.  This recipe is one that comes from my grandma’s cookbook that she gives each grandchild when they graduate high school.  I have had mine for quite a few years now and am slowly picking out my favorites.  This happens to be one of them.  Every time I have made this for a party or an event with a lot of people, everyone always asks for this recipe.  It looks and tastes like you put in a lot of work, but believe me when I tell you it whips up SO quick!It only has 3 ingredients with an optional 4th ingredient!  It doesn’t get easier than that!Pin ItICE CREAM SANDWICH CAKEapproximately 22-24 ice cream sandwiches1 pint of butterscotch caramel ice cream topping12 oz. cool whipslivered almonds (optional)Unwrap and line bottom of 9″ x 13″ pan with approximately 11-12 ice cream sandwiches.  Trim to make layer smooth and even.  Spoon on and spread about 1/2 pint of butterscotch caramel ice cream topping.  Spoon on and spread half of the cool whip.  Repeat layers of ice cream sandwiches, butterscotch caramel topping, and cool whip.  Sprinkle top with slivered almonds.  Freeze until serving.Enjoy!Linking up to these parties and here

Leave a Comment



  1. 1

    This is actually a favorite summer dessert in our family that my mom makes! She layers it with toasted pecans and calls it a turtle ice cream cake! So glad to see you like it, too. :)This picture looks dreamy, btw!Merry ChristmasLeslie

  2. 2

    Oh my does that look good — a sundae on a plate :)

  3. 3

    WOW, I thought my Ice Cream Salad was simplenut this "takes the cake."

  4. 4

    I have a son that is crazy about ice cream sandwhiches; garentee he will go crazy for this when I serve it for Sunday dinner! Thanks!

  5. 5

    ooooo my friend made something like this before except some how she spiked it and added something like kalua in it. Crazy! That looks wonderful!

  6. 6

    I can't believe that is made from ice cream sandwiches, it looks so complicated and so gormet! I will be trying this soon.

  7. 7

    Well, that sure looks good and easy. We all like those kinds of desserts. Your recipe index is very nice. I want one. Makes finding recipes much easier. Good job andi

  8. 8

    Oh yum! This looks so amazing and it's pretty too!

  9. 9

    This comment has been removed by the author.

  10. 10

    i had this last weekend at a party. sooo good!

  11. 11

    looks amazing!

  12. 12

    Yum! I will definitely have to try this!Stopping in from the FT Think Pink Party

  13. 13

    OH My, I gained 10 lbs just looking at that picture!!